Silvercryst Supper Club Resort & Motel

Situated in the heart of Wautoma, Wisconsin, Silvercryst Supper Club Resort & Motel artfully blends the warmth of a classic supper club with the comfort of a cozy motel, making it a distinctive destination for both dining and lodging. Whether you're here to enjoy a memorable meal or a restful stay, Silvercryst brings genuine hospitality and a touch of nostalgic charm to every guest experience.

As a restaurant, Silvercryst Supper Club prides itself on serving hearty, traditional American fare with a distinctive supper club flair. The menu showcases a rich variety of comfort classics and elevated favorites that tempt the palate with bold flavors and satisfying portions. Star dishes such as the Famous Silvercryst Broasted Chicken—a crispy, juicy half chicken kissed with golden broasting perfection—never fail to keep guests coming back. The steak offerings, including the melt-in-your-mouth Tenderloin Steak, the robust Double Top Sirloin for Two, and the Broiled Steak sandwich, cater beautifully to carnivores craving tender, expertly cooked cuts.

Seafood lovers will find delights like the fresh, flaky Salmon served alongside baked potatoes or paired with sweet potato fries and asparagus, offering a lovely balance of flavors and textures. The Fish Fry, a Wisconsin tradition, shines here with tender fish and a soul-warming side of mashed sweet potatoes glazed with honey butter—a combination that leaves a lasting impression. For those wanting lighter fare, the Chef's Salad combines crisp, vibrant greens with your choice of tender chicken, shrimp, or salmon, providing a refreshing counterpoint to the richer menu items.

The Silvercryst also knows how to elevate the drink experience with handcrafted cocktails that embody both classic and tropical influences. Their Brandy Old Fashioned Sweet and Bloody Mary are local legends, praised by patrons for their perfect balance and inviting aromas. Fans of sweeter sips enjoy the smooth Moscato and the tropical Pina Colada, rounding out the dining experience with vibrant, flavorful libations.

Dining at Silvercryst is more than just a meal; it’s stepping into a welcoming space where the atmosphere resonates with the cozy, nostalgic charm of a traditional Wisconsin supper club. Guests often mention the warm, friendly service, noting how attentive staff foster an inviting ambiance that feels like dining at a longtime family favorite. The bar area offers a laid-back vibe, perfect for savoring drinks before or after dinner.

For travelers or locals seeking comfortable accommodations, Silvercryst’s motel offers clean, well-appointed rooms that provide excellent value. Guest reviews highlight the accommodating, friendly staff and the ease of pairing a peaceful stay with delicious meals. Whether you’re unwinding after a day on the road or extending your visit to explore beautiful Wautoma, the Silvercryst Motel provides a restful haven with a personal touch.

Real experiences from visitors capture the soul of Silvercryst perfectly: Natasha appreciated the top-notch service paired with classic dishes, while Jeff raved about the Old Fashioned cocktails and the comfort of the fish fry. Will praised the perfectly cooked chef’s prime cut and tenderloin shrimp dish, complemented by the attentive hospitality. Celebratory occasions, like Rabe’s family birthday gathering, are elevated by the supper club’s vibrant energy and mouthwatering broasted chicken that’s both crispy and juicy—proof of Silvercryst’s commitment to delivering traditions with heart.

Silvercryst Supper Club Resort & Motel stands as a cherished staple in Wautoma—a place where guests can cherish familiar flavors, warm welcomes, and a stay that feels like coming home. Whether you’re craving a rich, comforting meal or a quiet night’s rest, this local gem offers an experience that lingers with you long after the last bite or check-out.